Review: Cory Doctrow’s Makers

I first encountered Cory Doctrow with his geeky little book called Little Brother.  It had the energy of Snow Crash with all the nerdy technology and anti-establishment tone you could conceivably want.  Makers tries the same thing except the technology isn’t as cool and sticking it to the Man gets tiresome.

The book opens from the perspective of a journalist covering two crazy inventor partners who are the poster boys of a new economic system where large corporations fund small groups of R&D.  Yeah it doesn’t sound as unique as the book makes it out to be.  We have this system already with start-ups and venture capital, but nevermind.  Furthermore, the stuff spewing out of their lab is of dubious quality.  Admittedly it would be hard for the author to come up with legitimately profitable ideas, but this stuff felt subpar.  Their big dream is 3d printers that print 3d printers, as if self replication hasn’t been discussed to death.

This part of the book mostly thrives on some good character development and the general feeling that these people want and are able to change the world for the less fortunate.  However, the second part jumps forward a few years and the whole New Work movement pioneered by the aforementioned inventors has died with no word from the author as to why.  This is particularly puzzling given that 20% of the workforce was engaged in such activities and according to the book were quite successful in churning out new things.  So what is the economic order now and what about the aftermath of displacing so many people from their New Work?  We will never know.

Our protagonists now operate a ride memorializing these golden days.  It’s actually a very cool ride that is constantly changing based on user feedback.  I am not sure a ride is the best use for this particular invention, but that does not diminish the idea.  The idea spreads like wildfire and starts to span the globe and develops a cult following.  Where it really goes off the rails is when Disney Parks steps in with a big fat lawsuit against the ride and its ilk.  At this point Perry, one of the inventors, starts acting like a big baby hurting his friends and decrying that he doesn’t want to play by society’s rules.  In fact everyone acts kind of stupid here as the author establishes his anti-patent credentials and mixes in some unnecessary romantic drama.  The book has too many characters at this point, many of which have interesting story arcs that go nowhere.   One particular character that works for Disney starts by sabotaging the ride and roughing up one of his employees, but in the end we are supposed to believe he isn’t that bad and just wants to bring joy to the world.

To end the book is an overlong epilogue where the author casually dismisses some more of the relationships from earlier in the book and we find out that Lester, the other inventor of the duo, has been working for the Man at Disney.  He is also dying from some gene therapy that increased metabolism and muscle mass.  Apparently it’s not obvious that eating 10,000 calories a day is not good for your body or that maybe they could have tuned that number much lower while still keeping people thin.  Anyway the characters end up back where they started working on some mechanical computer idea that shows up throughout the novel and is not in the least bit interesting.

This is really the worst of science fiction having the awful characters endemic of the genre while simultaneously failing to create a viable world or interesting technological ideas or consequences.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s