Super Mario Galaxy – Like its sequel, overrated but still really good.
World in Conflict – Best RTS in a long freaking time.
Portal – Yeah it’s really good and funny.
God of War 2
Project Gotham Racing 4, Fora Motorsport 2, Dirt
Unreal Torunament 3 – Don’t make them like this any more.
The Witcher – A simplistic combat system and some grindy areas hold back an otherwise great RPG.
Bioshock – See Bioshock 2
Uncharted – See rest of series.
Ninja Gaiden – I didn’t care for the rebooted games at all; consider this a stand in for them.
Mass Effect – Clunky combat and overwrought inventory system weigh down what is actually a pretty good RPG.
Super Paper Mario – Been a huge fan of this RPG series since the SNES, but this felt rushed and ugly and the 2D bits were just bad.
Metroid Prime 3 – What did they do to my beloved series?